Chapter 2 - The False Father
The room grew icy cold. Rachel felt Eli’s fingers digging into her wrist with a force born of absolute terror. His small hand was trembling violently, but his eyes were wide, clear, and intensely focused on her.
"What do you mean, Eli?" Detective Brooks asked, stepping between the boy and the doorway. His hand rested instinctively near his sidearm. "What else is on that doll?"
"It’s not what’s on the recorder," Eli whispered, refusing to break eye contact with Rachel. "It’s where the doll came from. Mark thinks he owns everything in that house. He checks the cameras. He counts the keys. But he didn't know Mom hid Lucy’s real birth certificate inside the lining of the doll’s head before he took her."
Before Brooks could ask another question, the interview room door swung open wider.
A tall man stepped into the threshold. He wore an expensive wool coat, neatly styled brown hair, and carried himself with the smooth, calm authority of someone accustomed to being obeyed. This was Mark Halston. His smile was warm and practiced, but his eyes—cold, calculating gray—swept the room in a single second, taking in Rachel, the detective, and the small boy cowering in the chair.
"Eli, buddy," Mark said softly, his voice thick with performative concern. "Thank God you're safe. I was beside myself with worry when I realized you were out of your bed."
Mark stepped into the room, holding out a hand toward the boy. "Detective, I apologize for all this trouble. My stepson has been severely traumatized since his mother... well, since Sarah abandoned us last month. He suffers from night terrors and sleepwalking. He makes up elaborate stories."
"I don't sleepwalk," Eli hissed, shrinking further behind Rachel. "And Mom didn't abandon us! You did something to her!"
Mark sighed heavily, shaking his head with a look of pained patience. "See what I mean? It’s heartbreaking. He's mixing up his grief with reality. Sarah couldn't handle the stress of the new baby, Detective. She packed her bags and left four weeks ago. Lucy was sent to stay with Sarah’s sister, Clara, in Vermont, while I sorted out the legal guardianship."
"Vermont?" Brooks asked neutrally. "That’s funny, Mr. Halston. We just pulled up the registration on your residence. Sarah Carter is still listed as the primary deed holder. And we have a recording found inside a toy your stepson left on Mrs. Bennett’s porch."
Mark didn't flinch. Not even a twitch of an eye. He simply tilted his head, his expression shifting smoothly from concern to mild amusement.
"A recording?" Mark said softly. "Detective, I run a security firm specializing in audio and video monitoring. I have hundreds of voice samples, testing files, and home security feeds on my hard drives. Eli loves playing with my old tech equipment. If you’re basing police action on a fragment of spliced audio chopped together by an emotionally disturbed ten-year-old, I suggest you consult your legal team first."
Rachel felt her blood run cold. Mark was dangerous—not because he was muscular or intimidating, but because he was intelligent, prepared, and entirely devoid of panic.
"Mr. Halston," Rachel interrupted, her voice surprisingly steady despite the pounding in her chest. "Eli ran miles through a freezing rainstorm barefoot. That isn't sleepwalking. That’s a child running for his life."
Mark finally looked directly at Rachel. His eyes locked onto her pregnant belly, a subtle, cruel smirk touching the edge of his lips. "Mrs. Bennett, isn't it? The grieving widow from Oak Street. I deeply sympathize with your condition, but you know nothing about my family. You’re letting your own... tragic loss... cloud your judgment."
The insult was quiet, but it hit Rachel like a physical blow. Mentioning Daniel was a deliberate move to disarm her.
Brooks stepped directly in Mark’s line of sight. "Mr. Halston, you’re not taking Eli anywhere tonight. Not until Child Protective Services reviews this situation, and not until I verify the whereabouts of baby Lucy with the Vermont State Police."
Mark’s smile vanished completely. The warmth left his face, leaving behind a sharp, predatory mask. "You have no legal cause to detain my stepson, Detective. You have no warrant. You have no physical evidence of a crime."
"I have a child asking for protection," Brooks said quietly. "That's all the cause I need for twenty-four hours."
Mark stared at Brooks for a long, silent moment. Then, slowly, he backed out of the room. "You're making a catastrophic mistake, Detective. And Mrs. Bennett... I suggest you go home and take care of yourself. Pregnant women shouldn't stress themselves over things that don't belong to them."
He turned and walked down the hallway, his leather shoes clicking rhythmically against the tile floor.
Eli let out a ragged breath and collapsed against Rachel’s side. "He’s going to move her," the boy sobbed into her sweater. "He's going to take Lucy away forever now!"
Rachel wrapped her arms around the trembling boy, her own baby kicking hard against her ribs. She looked up at Detective Brooks.
May you like
"He's right, isn't he?" Rachel asked. "Mark is going to destroy whatever evidence he has."
Brooks reached into his pocket and pulled out the blue plastic doll. "Not if we find what's inside this toy first."
