Chapter 6 - The Deposition

The formal depositions took place in a high-rise conference room overlooking Puget Sound.
Patricia Carter sat across from me, flanked by three high-priced defense attorneys. Even in a legal room, she tried to maintain her aristocratic posture, wearing a dark blue Chanel suit. But she couldn't hide the tremor in her hands or the sunken hollows beneath her eyes. The strain of her public disgrace was eating her alive.
Beside her sat Claire, looking nervous, constantly biting her lip.
Eleanor opened the proceedings. "State your full name for the record."
"Patricia Montgomery Carter," she replied, her voice icy.
"Mrs. Carter, on the morning of June 14th, did you pick up your granddaughter, Lily Carter, from Oakridge Elementary?"
"I did," Patricia said coldly. "She was complaining of feeling unwell. I believed she was throwing a temper tantrum to get out of her end-of-year exams."
"Did Nurse Jenkins hand you an EpiPen and explicitly tell you that Lily was having a severe allergic reaction to peanuts?" Eleanor asked, leaning forward.
Patricia's attorney intervened. "Objection. Calls for a legal conclusion regarding medical severity."
"I am asking what the nurse said to her," Eleanor replied smoothly. "Answer the question, Mrs. Carter."
Patricia tightened her jaw. "The nurse was overly dramatic. School staff these days panic over every little scratch. I have raised three children, Miss Vance. I know when a child is actually sick and when they are looking for attention."
"So you overruled a trained medical professional?" Eleanor pressed.
"I used my judgment as a mother and grandmother!" Patricia snapped.
"And was your 'judgment' to leave a gasping ten-year-old child on the sofa of a neighbor who was not informed of her medical condition, while you drove to a lake club for a mimosa?"
"We had reservations!" Patricia blurted out, her composure finally breaking. "The family had worked hard all week! We couldn't let one of Lily's endless dramatic episodes ruin a day we had planned for months! She was fine! She was breathing!"
The entire room fell dead silent. Even her own defense attorneys looked down at their notepad, visibly cringing at the sheer arrogance recorded by the court reporter.
Eleanor slowly pulled out a tablet and hit play.
The audio recording of the 911 call played through the high-definition speakers in the room. Mrs. DeLuca’s panicked voice filled the room: "Please hurry! She can't breathe! Her lips are blue! Her grandmother just dropped her off and left! She's choking!"
Behind that voice was the horrific, agonizing sound of my ten-year-old daughter gasping for air, making terrifying, wheezing noises as her throat closed up.
Claire burst into tears, covering her face. Patricia turned utterly ghost-white.
"Is that 'drama', Mrs. Carter?" Eleanor asked quietly, her tone utterly ruthless. "Is that a child looking for attention?"
May you like
Patricia couldn't answer. She stared at the recorder, her lips trembling, unable to utter a single word.
"No further questions," Eleanor said, shutting off the tablet. "We will see you at the criminal trial."