Chapter 3 - The Search at the House
The sun had completely dipped below the horizon by the time Mark’s battered Honda Civic pulled into my driveway behind my truck. The sky was an bruised shade of purple and slate gray, matching the cold dread sitting squarely in my chest.
We had stopped at a brightly lit supercenter along the way. Lily had picked out a pair of oversized dinosaur pajamas and a plush stuffed bear with neon pink ears. She thought we were having an unexpected sleepover adventure at Grandpa’s house. She didn't know why her father’s eyes were bloodshot, or why I kept checking my rearview mirror every two blocks to make sure no one was following us.
Inside my house, the kettle was whistling softly on the stove. I had made a pot of hot chamomile tea with honey for Lily, watching her closely as she took her first sip—checking the color, smelling the steam—before trusting it enough to drink. That broke my heart all over again. A seven-year-old child shouldn't have to audit her own beverages for poison.
Once Lily was tucked into the spare bedroom bed with her new pink-eared bear and a stack of old storybooks, Mark and I sat at my laminate kitchen table.
“The police and the caseworker finished their initial intake statement over the phone,” Mark said, staring down at his phone screen. Detective Miller from the Columbus Police Department had listened to Dr. Harrison’s report, reviewed the toxicology numbers via secure electronic transfer, and immediately flagged the case as a felony-level endangerment and poisoning investigation.
“What about Natalie?” I asked, sliding a mug of black coffee across the table to him.
“She texted me twenty minutes ago,” Mark said, his finger hovering over the screen. He turned the phone toward me so I could read the glowing blue bubbles.
Natalie: Where are you? Lily’s bedtime is in ten minutes. Did you pick up the organic milk I asked for?
Natalie: Mark. Answer your phone. Why is your car not in the driveway?
Natalie: Don't ignore me.
I read the timestamps. The gaps were getting shorter. The panic in her messages wasn't the panic of a mother wondering where her family was; it was the frantic anxiety of a criminal realizing her routine had been disrupted.
“She doesn't know we went to the doctor,” Mark whispered, rubbing his temples. “She thinks we’re just running late. She thinks she can still control the narrative.”
“She can’t,” I said firmly. “Detective Miller is securing a search warrant for your house right now based on Dr. Harrison’s medical findings and the witness statement from Lily. They’re going to search every inch of that kitchen. They’re going to find whatever bottles, powders, or liquid droppers she’s been using.”
Mark stood up abruptly, pacing the small linoleum kitchen. The floorboards creaked under his heavy boots. “I need to go back there, Dad. I left my laptop on the kitchen counter, and... and I need to check the home security system hard drive. We have indoor cameras in the hallway and the kitchen nook. If she’s been drugging Lily for months, there might be footage.”
I stood up with him. “You’re not going alone. We wait for Detective Miller to arrive at your street, or we go in with the police.”
“No,” Mark said, looking at me with a sudden, fierce determination. “The police won’t be at our house for another hour because they’re waiting for a judge to sign off on the emergency after-hours warrant. But Natalie is alone right now. If I go back under the guise of grabbing my work laptop and checking on things before the storm hits, I can secure the hard drive from the security hub in the pantry before she realizes the game is up.”
May you like
“That’s dangerous, Mark,” I warned, grabbing my jacket off the wooden peg by the door. “If she suspects anything—”
“I’m not leaving my daughter’s safety to chance, and I’m not letting her destroy the digital evidence while we wait for paperwork,” Mark interrupted, pulling his car keys from his pocket. “Come with me, Dad. You stay in the truck at the end of the block and keep watch. If she leaves the house or if anything looks wrong, you call me immediately. But I’m going inside.”
