Chapter 7 - Secrets in the Attic
The diner on 4th Street smelled of stale coffee, fried grease, and old vinyl booths. It was nearly empty at 3:00 PM on a Tuesday, save for a truck driver dozing over a mug of black coffee in the far corner.
I pushed open the glass door, the small bell chiming overhead, and immediately spotted Taylor sitting in a corner booth near the back. She looked a decade older than when I had last seen her. Her hair was pulled back in a messy, unwashed bun, dark circles bruised the skin beneath her eyes, and her hands shook violently as she wrapped them around a lukewarm cup of tea.
I walked over and slid into the vinyl booth opposite her, not bothering to take off my jacket.
“You have five minutes, Taylor,” I said flatly, keeping my hands on the table. “What is this all about?”
Taylor didn't look up right away. She stared down into her tea, watching the dark liquid ripple as her hands trembled. Slowly, she reached into her large leather tote bag and pulled out a thick, yellowed manila envelope tied with a faded ribbon. She slid it across the sticky laminate table toward me.
“My mother's safety deposit box documents,” Taylor whispered, her voice barely audible. “And her personal journals from forty years ago.”
I looked at the envelope suspiciously. “Why are you giving me this?”
“Because she’s turning on me,” Taylor finally looked up, her eyes red-rimmed and filled with a desperate, frantic terror. “Yesterday at the jail, her attorney served me with a declaration claiming that I was the one who bought the freezer, I was the one who put Lily inside it, and that she merely walked in on it and tried to stop me. She’s throwing me under the bus to save herself from twenty years in prison.”
A cold anger flared in my chest, but I kept my voice icy. “And you expect me to feel sorry for you? You let her torture our daughter, Taylor. You are complicit.”
“I’m not asking for your pity!” Taylor snapped, a sudden flash of desperate defiance crossing her face before crumbling back into despair. “I’m asking you to look at the truth. Read what’s in that envelope, Ethan. Read about what happened to my older sister, Claire.”
I froze. The air in the diner seemed to grow heavy. “Your older sister? Taylor, you are an only child. You’ve told me a hundred times that you grew up an only child.”
Taylor let out a hollow, broken laugh. “That’s what my mother told me for the first time when I was ten years old. But it wasn't true. Claire existed. She was born four years before me. And she didn't survive my mother's ‘discipline.’”
My blood turned to ice water. I reached out slowly, untied the faded ribbon, and slid the contents of the manila envelope out onto the table.
Inside were birth certificates, old black-and-white hospital photographs from the late 1970s, and a series of spiral-bound notebooks filled with frantic, jagged handwriting. I pulled out the top photograph. It showed a toddler with bright, smiling eyes who looked astonishingly like Lily.
Beneath it was a medical examiner’s coroner report dated October 1982.
Cause of death: Severe accidental hypothermia and systemic shock following prolonged confinement in an unventilated refrigerated unit.
I looked up from the papers, my heart hammering against my ribs like a trapped bird. I stared straight into Taylor’s terrified, tear-stained eyes.
May you like
“Your mother,” I whispered, the words catching in my throat, “didn't just lock Lily in a freezer... she did this before.”
Taylor nodded, tears streaming freely down her cheeks. “She killed my sister forty years ago, Ethan. And she got away with it because the police back then ruled it a tragic household accident. My mother covered her tracks, lied to everyone, and then she had me a few years later to replace the child she destroyed. When Lily started acting out... when Lily inherited my stubbornness... my mother saw Claire in her. And the cycle started all over again.”
