Chapter 6 - What Was Stolen
The afternoon sun filtered through the high, dusty windows of the woodworking shop, casting long shafts of golden light across stacks of polished mahogany and oak.
Arthur Hayes sat on a wooden stool, his weathered hands clasped tightly together over his knees. Tears tracked silently through the sawdust on his cheeks as he listened to Daniel speak. He didn't interrupt once while Daniel recounted the decades of emotional abuse, the discovery of the file in Cornelius's study, the paternity report, and the horrific incident on the patio with Leo.
When Daniel finished, Arthur let out a long, ragged exhale that sounded like a sigh he had been holding in for thirty years.
"I tried to come back for you," Arthur said, his voice deep and raspy with age. "When Eleanor got sick, I drove back to town. I went to the house. But Cornelius had two county sheriffs waiting at the property line. He had an injunction against me, and he swore that if I ever tried to contact you, he would use his money to drag Eleanor through court until she died in a deposition room."
Arthur wiped his eyes with the back of his sleeve, looking up at Daniel with a mixture of profound sorrow and unbearable pride.
"She was so fragile at the end, Daniel. She wrote to me and begged me to stay away. She said... she said if I stayed away, Cornelius would at least give you his name and a home. I thought I was protecting you by leaving. I thought if I disappeared, he would treat you like his own."
"He treated me like a prisoner," Daniel said quietly, though there was no anger in his voice toward Arthur—only a deep, resonant sadness for what could have been. "He hated me because every time he looked at me, he saw you."
"I am so sorry, son," Arthur choked out, the word son hanging in the warm, wood-scented air between them with heavy, beautiful gravity. "I am so, so sorry."
"Don't be," I spoke up gently from the doorway.
Leo had gotten restless in the car, so I had brought him up to the open entrance of the barn. He was holding his plastic golf tee in one hand and a small block of smooth cedar he had picked up near the door in the other.
Arthur looked over at us, his eyes softening as he spotted the six-year-old boy standing beside me.
"Is this...?" Arthur started.
"This is Leo," Daniel said, a soft, genuine smile spreading across his face—the first real smile I had seen on my husband in weeks. "Leo, this is... this is your grandfather Arthur."
Leo looked at Arthur, examining the old man’s sawdust-covered flannel shirt and warm, gentle eyes. Then he looked down at the wooden block in his hand.
"Did you make this building?" Leo asked, stepping into the shop without a trace of the fear he always had around Cornelius.
Arthur wiped his cheek, cleared his throat, and knelt down on the wooden floor so he was eye-level with the little boy. "I did, little man. I built every inch of it."
May you like
"It smells like Christmas trees," Leo said, offering the cedar block back to Arthur. "Grandpa Cornelius’s house smells like old carpet and mean words."
Arthur’s chest heaved as he let out a soft, emotional laugh. He gently pushed the wooden block back into Leo's small hands. "You keep that block, Leo. And as long as I'm around, nobody is ever going to use mean words around you again."
