Chapter 5 - The Legal Battle Begins
Three weeks later, Emily and Noah were finally discharged from the hospital. The physical scars were beginning to heal—Noah's skin was smooth again, and Emily was regaining her strength—but the emotional wounds were deep and volatile. Every time a door clicked shut too loudly, Emily would jump, her eyes wide with panic. Every time Noah cried for more than a few seconds, a look of sheer desperation would cross her face.
We couldn't return to our old rental house. The memories trapped within those walls were too toxic. With the help of Mr. Harris, our kind neighbor who packed up our belongings for us, I rented a small, sunlit apartment on the opposite side of Columbus, in a quiet neighborhood surrounded by parks and oak trees.
But true peace was impossible, because the trial was looming.
My mother and sister had hired a high-priced, aggressive defense attorney named Richard Vance (no relation to the detective), funded by a hidden savings account my mother had kept secret for years. They were planning to plead not guilty, claiming that Emily was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis and had brought the injuries upon herself and the baby, and that Linda and Ashley were merely trying to protect the child from an unstable mother.
"It's a disgusting tactic, but it's all they have," our victim advocate, Sarah Jenkins, told us during a meeting at the prosecutor's office. "They are going to try to paint Emily as erratic, emotional, and incompetent. They will use the fact that she was unconscious and unable to give a coherent statement initially to their advantage."
Emily sat beside me, clutching my hand so tightly her knuckles turned white. "They are going to tell the world I tried to hurt my own son?" she asked, her voice trembling.
"They can try," I said, my voice fiercely calm. "But they have to go through me first."
The depositions began a week later. I was called in first. Sitting across a long mahogany table from Richard Vance, the defense attorney, I felt a toxic mix of rage and disgust.
"Mr. Miller," Vance said, adjusting his expensive glasses. "Is it not true that your wife had been crying frequently prior to your departure? Is it not true that she expressed feeling overwhelmed by the duties of motherhood?"
"She had just given birth seven days prior, counselor," I replied coldly. "She was tired, yes. But she loved our son more than life itself. She was completely capable."
"Yet, you left her," Vance countered, a nasty smirk playing on his lips. "If she was so capable, why did you feel the need to beg your mother and sister to stay and supervise her?"
"I didn't ask them to supervise her," I spat back, leaning forward, staring directly into the attorney’s eyes. "I asked them to assist her so she could rest and heal. I expected them to act like human beings. Instead, they acted like captors. They locked a twenty-three-year-old healing woman and a seven-day-old infant in separate rooms without food or formula. That isn't a family dispute, Mr. Vance. That is attempted murder."
Vance tried to rattle me for three hours, digging into our finances, our marriage, and our past. But I held firm. I recounted every phone call, every lie my mother told me, every warning sign I had foolishly missed.
When the deposition ended, I walked out into the hallway and saw my sister Ashley sitting on a bench, waiting for her turn. She looked different—her expensive clothes replaced by a plain gray jumpsuit, her wrists bound by heavy handcuffs.
When she saw me, her eyes filled with crocodile tears. "Ethan, please," she whimpered. "Tell them to let me go. Mom forced me to do it! She said if I didn't help her, she would take away my car and kick me out. I didn't want the baby to get hurt! You have to believe me!"
I stopped and looked down at her. I remembered her laughing on the phone while my son suffocated in a hot room.
May you like
"You had a choice, Ashley," I said softly, feeling nothing but a profound sense of pity and disgust. "You chose a car over an innocent baby's life. Enjoy the consequences."
I turned my back on her cries and walked away, ready for the real battle to begin.
