Chapter 6 - The Paper Trail of Murders Past
“Drop the crowbar, Caleb,” Margaret hissed, her finger trembling against the trigger. “Or I put a hole through your heart right now.”
I froze. The cold, dark barrel of the gun was focused squarely on my sternum. At this distance, even an inexperienced shooter couldn't miss.
“You won’t shoot me, Margaret,” I said, forcing my voice to remain steady while my heart hammered in my throat. “The police are outside. The house is surrounded. The moment a gun goes off, they will breach this room.”
“Then I’ll kill you, take your truck keys, and leave through the basement exit before they even make it up the stairs!” her voice cracked with unhinged desperation. “You took my legacy, Caleb! You took my reputation! I won’t let you take my freedom!”
“Your freedom was gone the second you put liquid digitalis into Grace’s coffee,” I said, slowly lowering the crowbar an inch at a time, keeping her talking, playing for seconds. “The hospital already confirmed the poison in her blood. The tox report is sealed. Detective Vance knows everything about Arthur’s estate, too. Victoria went to the police.”
At the mention of Victoria’s name, Margaret’s left eye twitched violently. A flicker of genuine panic flashed across her face.
“Victoria knows nothing!” Margaret snarled.
“Victoria knows you emptied the three-million-dollar trust,” I countered, taking half an inch of a step forward. “She knows you forged Arthur’s signature on the trust amendments. She knows you murdered Arthur when he threatened to expose you.”
“Shut up!” Margaret screamed, raising the gun slightly higher, her knuckles turning white. “Shut your mouth!”
“Drop the weapon, Margaret!”
Detective Vance’s voice thundered from the hallway behind me.
Margaret’s eyes darted toward the doorway for a split second—a fraction of a moment of distraction.
It was all I needed.
I didn't think. I reacted. I swung the iron crowbar upward with all the force in my body, striking the underside of Margaret’s right wrist.
CRACK.
The gun went off with a deafening pop, the bullet shattering the glass frame of Grace and my wedding picture on the wall behind me. Margaret shrieked in pain as the revolver flew from her broken wrist and clattered across the hardwood floor.
Before she could react, I tackled her to the floor, pinning her arms behind her back.
Detective Vance and two armed officers burst into the room, their weapons raised.
“Clear! Clear!” Vance shouted, quickly stepping over us and kicking the nickel-plated revolver out of Margaret’s reach.
Vance pulled me up off the carpet, giving my shoulder a hard, approving squeeze. “Are you hit, Vance?”
“I’m fine,” I breathed, gasping for air, my heart hammering against my ribs. “She’s all yours.”
Two uniformed officers pulled Margaret to her feet. The polished, aristocratic matriarch was gone. Her hair was a wild nest, her expensive cardigan torn, and her face twisted in a ugly, spitting rage as the steel handcuffs clicked around her wrists.
“You ruin everything!” Margaret screamed at me, her voice shrill and echoing down the hallway as they dragged her backward toward the stairs. “You’re nothing! You’re just a stupid carpenter! Grace will hate you for this! Do you hear me? She will hate you!”
“Grace is alive,” I said, looking her dead in the eye as she was hauled away. “And that means you lost.”
Detective Vance stayed behind in the room while the officers escorted Margaret down to the waiting police cruiser. He walked over to the open duffel bag on the bed and flipped through the contents with a gloved hand.
Inside were stacks of bound hundred-dollar bills, three fake passports bearing Margaret’s picture under different names, and a black leather journal.
Vance opened the black leather journal and flipped through the handwritten pages. His eyes widened.
“Caleb,” Vance called out, his voice quiet and solemn. “Look at this.”
I walked over to the bed and looked over his shoulder.
The journal was a meticulous, chilling logbook kept by Margaret over the past ten years. In neat, elegant cursive, she had documented dates, dosages, and chemical interactions.
There were entries detailing Arthur’s slow decline—dates when he experienced “dizziness,” “nausea,” and “slow heart rate,” leading up to his final, fatal dose.
And on the last few pages were entries for Grace.
“October 12: Initiated micro-dose in morning tea. Grace complained of mild headache.”“October 18: Increased digitalis drop to 3ml. Yellow vision reported. Perfect.”“November 2: Final phase required before December 1st trust audit.”
I felt sick to my stomach. It wasn't just a sudden crime of passion or a desperate cover-up. Margaret was a cold-blooded, methodical serial murderer who had turned poisoning into a calculated science.
“This journal guarantees she dies in a state penitentiary,” Detective Vance said, closing the book carefully and placing it into an evidence bag. “She’ll never see the light of day again.”
May you like
I took a deep breath, looking around our mess of a bedroom, then at the shattered wedding photo on the wall. The frame was broken, but under the cracked glass, Grace and I were smiling, holding each other on a sunny afternoon five years ago.
“I need to go back to my wife,” I said.
