Chapter 2 - The Dark Beneath the Surface
The silence in the backyard felt heavier than the white-hot heat. Emily’s small fingers clawed into the fabric of my shirt, her breath hitched in shallow, terrified gasps. Her eyes were fixed on the deep end of the pool, where those heavy black contractor bags sat submerged in the murky green water.
"Daddy, please," she sobbed into my shoulder. "We have to go. Before he comes back down."
Above us, the heavy curtain on the second-floor window twitched. A shadow blocked the light for a second before retreating. Jason was up there.
I didn't care about Jason. I didn't care about anything except getting Emily over that fence. But my eyes darted back to the pool. A dark, oily film was floating toward the drain, and the shape of the bags was unmistakable. My mind raced through horrifying possibilities—what had Jason done? What was in those bags?
"Okay, baby. I’m holding you. We’re leaving right now," I whispered, tightening my grip around her trembling frame.
I shoved my foot into a notch on the wooden fence, heaving us both over into Mrs. Harris’s side yard. We hit the grass hard. Mrs. Harris was waiting, her hands clasped around her rosary, tears spilling over her wrinkled cheeks.
"Take her inside, Mrs. Harris," I said, my voice dangerously low. "Lock the doors. Call 911 right now. Tell them a child was held captive, and tell them to send homicide."
Emily whimpered, reaching for me again. "Don't go back, Daddy! Please!"
"I'm right here, sweetheart. I'm just watching the door until the police get here. No one is touching you ever again."
I stood on Mrs. Harris's porch, shielding Emily with my body while monitoring Sarah’s back door. Less than five minutes later, sirens wailed in the distance, growing louder until two patrol cars screeched to a halt in front of the house.
Two officers stepped out, guns drawn as I yelled to them from the lawn, pointing toward the back. I showed them Emily—her split lip, the bruised wrists where the cage had scraped her, the sheer terror in her eyes. Within moments, more cruisers arrived, followed by an ambulance.
While paramedics wrapped Emily in a warm blanket inside the emergency vehicle, officers kicked down Sarah’s front door. Minutes later, they dragged Jason out in handcuffs. He was yelling, shouting about his rights, his eyes wildly searching the crowd until they met mine. He didn't look like a tough man anymore; he looked like a cornered animal. Sarah followed shortly behind him, pale, silent, her eyes completely empty as she was loaded into a separate car.
Then came the dive team.
I stood by the ambulance, holding Emily’s hand while the paramedics checked her vitals. I tried to shield her gaze, but we both watched as two officers in wet suits hauled the heavy black bags out of the green pool.
When the head detective walked over to me, his face was ash-gray. He pulled off his gloves, looking at me with a mixture of profound relief and deep sorrow.
"Mr. Carter," the detective said quietly. "Your ex-wife and her husband are going away for a very long time."
"What was in the bags?" I asked, my heart hammering against my ribs.
May you like
"Evidence," he replied grimly. "Hard drives, destroyed family heirlooms, a blood-soaked rug, and the remains of Sarah’s family dog—he used it to intimidate your daughter. If you hadn't come today, your daughter was next."
The air left my lungs completely. I pulled Emily into my lap inside the ambulance, burying my face in her hair, weeping quietly as the reality of how close I had come to losing her set in.
