Chapter 3 - The Patio Stranger
“Rachel! Look at this!” I shouted, thrusting my phone toward my sister.
Rachel dropped her dish towel and stared at the screen. The figure on the patio turned their head slowly, as if sensing the lens staring back at them, then raised a hand and pressed their palm flat against the glass of the camera. The screen distorted into black-and-white grain before cutting to a connection error message.
“They’re at the house,” Rachel whispered, her face pale. “How did they know we were in Raleigh?”
“Because they’re watching us,” I said, adrenaline flooding my veins with cold, sharp clarity. “They’re not just after the house. They’re after Emma.”
I dialed 911 again, shouting our location in Raleigh and giving the Fayetteville address to dispatch, explaining that an active trespasser was on the property. The dispatcher promised to coordinate with Cumberland County authorities.
At the same time, I called Daniel.
His phone rang four times before going straight to voicemail.
“Damn it, Daniel, pick up,” I muttered.
Twenty minutes later, my phone pinged with a text message from Daniel: Just landed at RDU. Flight was delayed. Coming straight to Rachel’s.
When Daniel arrived, he looked frantic. He burst through Rachel’s front door, dropping his duffel bag in the hallway, and pulled me into a tight embrace.
“Are you okay? What happened?”
“They called me, Daniel. They’re at our house right now. The police are searching the perimeter, but whoever it is has a key.”
Daniel pulled back, his brow furrowed in genuine confusion and concern. “A key? How? We’re the only ones who have copies.”
“My parents passed away. Your parents live in Florida and haven’t visited in two years. We haven't given a spare to anyone except—” I stopped.
“Except who?” Daniel asked.
“Except Sarah.”
Sarah was our former next-door neighbor in Fayetteville. She had moved away six months ago, but when we went on a three-week deployment-readiness exercise last year, she held our spare key to water the plants and feed our cat.
“Sarah moved to Wilmington,” Daniel said, shaking his head. “And she adored Emma. Why would she do something like this?”
“I don’t know. But we are going to find out.”
Early the next morning, despite Daniel’s pleas to stay put, I insisted we drive back to Fayetteville. Rachel came with us, refusing to let me face it alone.
When we arrived at our brick house, two police cruisers were parked out front. Deputy Harris was leaning against his hood, looking grim.
“We searched the property, Mrs. Carter,” Harris said as we stepped out of the car. “No one was inside. All the new locks are intact. But we found something on your back patio.”
He handed me a small plastic evidence bag.
Inside was a single, rusted brass key.
I stared at it. It wasn't one of our new locks. It was the old key to the back deadbolt—the one I thought I had thrown away three years ago when we first moved in.
“Who had access to this?” Harris asked.
“No one,” I said softly. “At least, no one I knew.”
Daniel stood beside me, wrapping a supportive arm around my shoulder. “Officer, my wife has been under immense strain. Is it possible an old tenant left a duplicate?”
“Possible,” Harris said, though his eyes remained skeptical. “Or someone took it from a hiding spot.”
That night, we stayed in a local motel. Sleep was impossible. While Daniel and Emma slept, I sat at the small formica desk with my laptop open, logging into military database logs, local property records, and old neighborhood directories. I needed to know who owned this house before us.
The deed history went back twenty years.
Before us, it belonged to a man named Arthur Vance.
I searched his name in local court archives. What I found made my blood run cold.
May you like
Arthur Vance hadn't just owned the house. In 2012, his one-year-old daughter, Lily, had mysteriously vanished from her crib in the exact same bedroom Emma was now sleeping in.
And the case had never been solved.
